WHY I HATE CRITICS
by Seth Fisher

George Bernard Shaw once said something very nasty about critics. I don't remember exactly what it was, but it was right.

Our last main stage show, ...apocalypse..., was met with violently differing opinions from the critics. They ranged from hateful and riddled with bad puns, to glowing with an intensity usually only seen in enriched plutonium. The one thing that all of them had in common was that I didn't want to hear them.

The first review was terrible. The reviewer was full of mean-spirited comments. One acid-tongued barb after another. Very witty. But with the comments that he made, I wondered if he had really watched the show at all. The review seemed like an encoded message for some local spy. There is a friend of mine in another theatre company that actually saw a reviewer nodding off at one of their shows, and they got a good review! Anyway, the review made it's way into the paper, into the hands of the actors and crew backstage, and in some way, onto the stage itself. We say that it doesn't effect us, that we don't let it effect our performance. Of course, I say this too, but somehow it happens. We don't like to admit it but it does. And it shouldn't. These people are not a part of our company. They are not fellow artists or contributors or collaborators. They are sideline coaches that snuck in without paying and are not on our team.

When the next review came out, Don called me at work.

"I just got the review, you want to hear it?"

I said, "No."

Then he read it to me. It was glowing. Amazing. A review that I would be sure to send to my mom.

Don said, "You still sound a little bummed."

I told him I was bummed. I don't only dislike the reviews when they are bad. It's the fact that they exist in the first place. Who the hell are these people that assume that we were out to impress them? That a play is good or bad depending on whether or not they like it? I suggested to Don that our shows be half price for actors and double for critics. He wouldn't go for it.

After the first review, I was explaining the situation to a guy that I work with who is from Iran. After several minutes of my bitching he said, "You mean, they write about a play even if they don't like it? They write bad things? Who would read it?"

I couldnít answer him.