![]() |
||
|
|
||
|
Some thoughts from smarter folks...
From David Mamet's "Writing In Restaurants": The essential task of the drama... is to offer a solution to a problem which is nonsusceptible to reason. To be effective, the drama must induce us to suspend our rational judgement, and to follow the *internal* logic of the piece, so that our *pleasure* (our "cure") is the release at the end of the story. We enjoy the happiness of being a participant in the process of *solution*, rather than the intellectual achievement of having observed the process of construction. And the best model for this drama is The Story around the Campfire. We hear "...a windswept moor" and immediately supply the perfect imaginary moor. And the moor we supply is not perfect "in general," but perfect according to our subconscious understanding of the significance of the moor *to the story*. *** We, as audience, are much better off with a sign that says A BLASTED HEATH, than with all the brilliant cinematography in the world. To say "brilliant cinematography" is to say, "He made the trains run on time." Witness the rather fascistic trend in cinema in the last decade. Q. How'd you like the movie? A. Fantastic cinematography. Yeah, but so what? Hitler had fantastic cinematography. The question we have ceased to ask is, "What was the fantastic or brilliant cinematography in *aid* of?" [from "Radio Drama"] There is a *vast* amount of talent in this coutry's theater - in the small theaters of Chicago, Boston, New york, Louisville, and Seattle, especially. Theatrical artists in these and other cities are working. They are acting, designing, directing, and writing plays constantly. Because they live in an atmosphere fairly free of commercial pressure, they have no need either to withhold their skills from the marketplace to drive up the price, or to pander to mercantile aesthetics; so they are developing their skills, their point of view, and their talent. Traditionally the movie industry has developed this talent by demonstrating to it how much better a Mercedes handles than a Chevy. [from "A Playwright In Hollywood"] "Writing in Restaurants" was published in 1986.
He's a bit more down on film as a legitimate art form than I like, but he makes some good points in the below segment (which is actually a letter he wrote to the New York Times in response to a theatre vs film debate two columnists had in its pages): Concerning movies versus theatre... may I present the following notions: He who has seen Laurence Olivier only on film has not seen Laurence Olivier. Marlon Brando's screen portrayal of Stanley Kowalski was but a fuzzy outline of his original stage creation. No film performance ever recorded can ever seriously challenge Laurette Taylor in "The Glass Menangerie" on stage. The film versions of "The Glass Menangerie," "Death of a Salesman," "Golden Boy," "Oklahoma!" "South Pacific," and even "A Streetcar Named Desire" are, one and all, faint echoes of vigorous stage work. Shakespeare, Shaw, O'Casey, O'Neill, Strindberg, Ibsen, Chekov, and Anouilh are rarely to never produced on film and a damned good thing, too, for in nearly every instance the results have been absurd. No significant playwright I know of has ever, repeat ever, done better work for the films than he has done for the stage.
If all this be so, why is it so?... Artistically speaking, a motion picture belongs to its director. Films are fundamentally graphic while the theatre is fundamentally poetic... motion pictures are not literary, not rhetorical - not even, strictly speaking, *emotional*. They are a mechanical product produced by a committee and stand in no need of the *individual human soul*, without which the theatre simply cannot function. In other words, films are basically dead (canned, not fresh, not alive - "in the can"), while the theatre is fundamentally electric. As for creativity, and despite these limitations, a director and his cameraman (or a writer-director) can express themselves very well in that their shot planning, cutting, and sequence of footage *force* a reaction from the audience in much the same way a card sharp forces a given card on his victim. This celluloid sleight-of-hand is the most creative activity in film-making - as well as the most fun. It is a fascinating skill and takes a lot of practice, but I doubt that it is an art. Even if it is, the playwright (*qua* playwright) and the actor have no artistic connection with such business. All they can do is surrender their carefully nurtured talents to the mechanics of the medium and bend to the camera's will. [from "Letters from an Actor" c1966]
And so forth. -Dave.
|
||
|
|
||